History and Status of Tehran Metro (Expenses, Future Projects)

Tarabaran; Economic and Transportation Monthly of Iran (Economic, Political and Social)
Dec. 1999, No. 9
Pages: 57 - 60
Word Count: 2681
original article published on Netiran.com


Summary: Construction work on line one of Tehran Metro was launched in Jahan Koudak lands in northern Tehran by the French company Suferto in 1978. The French company had to leave Tehran in 1981 and the operation resumed in 1986. In 1999, the first line of the metro which linked Tehran to Karaj, constructed at a total cost of hundreds of millions of rials became operational. To date, 1,500 billion rials plus 700 million dollars have been spent on the metro project. The prospect of heavy expenses needed to complete the project has caused it to proceed very slowly.

Text: It took nearly one century from the time when Qajar King Agha Mohammad Khan decided to choose Tehran as the capital city of the country to the time the wish of another Qajar King Nasereddin Shah for possessing a motor car came true. From that time onwards, Tehran became a city filled with a large number of cars mainly due to petro dollars pouring into the country and ambitious wishes cherished by the then statesmen of the country (that every Iranian should have a home-made Paykan car). Finally, heavy traffic jams, prolongation of trips in the capital city, air and sound pollutions and other traffic related problems gripping the capital city prompted all Iranian officials to find a way out of this plight. The existence of comfortable and luxury subways in Europe and America at last convinced all officials that construction of a metro is the only way to get the capital city out of the traffic problem. As a result, in 1970 the Plan and Budget Organization and the Municipality of Tehran announced an international tender for construction of a metro in Tehran. The French company Soferto , affiliated to the state-owned Transportations Company in Paris won the tender and in the same year began to conduct preliminary studies on the project.

Construction work on the first line of the Tehran Metro started in the unclaimed plots of lands in northern Tehran (today's Martyr Haqqani Highway) in 1978. But after the victory of the Islamic Revolution (Feb. 1979), the representatives of the French company left Iran in December 1980 and on March 3, 1982, the Cabinet ministers formally announced the stop of Tehran Metro operations by the French company. In 1984, the issue was seriously raised at the Islamic Consultative Assembly (Majlis) and at Friday prayer sermons and eventually in March 1985 the Cabinet ministers approved the implementation of the Tehran Metro project and subsequently, the second stage of construction began in the summer of 1986.

During the years when the metro was being constructed, officials in charge of the project once in a while spoke about the inauguration and commissioning of metro lines until in 1997 when the management of the project changed and Mohsen Hashemi (son of former president Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani) took over the management. Eventually after elapse of three decades -- or 14 years in the opinion of the Metro Company -- and spending of hundreds of billions of rials, Tehran-Karaj metro line was inaugurated by President Mohammad Khatami late last year. The construction of the Tehran Metro was started at a time when the official rate of (the U.S.) dollar against rial was 70 rials. Moreover, Tejarat, Sepah, Mellat and Melli banks have so far put 700 billion rials at the disposal of the Metro Company. The company has also been granted the concessions for exploitation of iron ore mines in Bandar Abbas (Hormuzgan Province), exploitation and sale of Moghan iron ore mine in Azarbaijan Province, export of fuel oil from Isfahan oil refinery as well as tar form Isfahan steel mill and so on. However, despite all these facilities put at the disposal of the Metro Company, we have managed so far to commission the 32 kilometer line between Tehran and Karaj without completing the stations located along this course. It is noteworthy that what has been commissioned as Tehran-Karaj metro line is the electric line of the project whereas in all other countries of the world, metro is first inaugurated and then electric train used to transport passengers from suburban areas to metro stations in the city. It however seems that the Iranian officials in charge of Tehran Metro have preferred to carry out the easier part of the project first and for this reason they have delivered the electric line before other major parts of the metro project.

WHAT'S UP DOWN THERE?

There is not much helpful information available on the Tehran Metro and the existing information is confined to those written in nice looking brochures and booklets. To know more about the construction operations and qualitative and quantitative progress of the project more precise studies are required. During the years when the project was being implemented little was heard from the officials in charge of the project about the technical and executive aspects of this great national plan, whereas there are more reliable and more complete information at hand on construction and financial cost of for example this or that rural road, as disseminated by the mass media. Will this project be accomplished as planned given the expectations it has generated? There is not a clear answer to this question. What has been heard once in a while about this national project over the past few years has pre-occupied people more than before.

A motor car packed with passengers which plunged into Qourkhaneh workshop (the central terminal of the metro in southern Tehran) as a result of the collapse of a wall of the tunnel resulting in the death of all passengers, the sinking of a ship carrying metro locomotives shortly after its departure from China en route to Iran, and disturbances in communication systems and in water and power networks along the courses of metro tunnels are among the news items which have served to keep alive the memory of metro in the minds of people. The only official news items released about the metro over the past few years were about the date of its inauguration which has been postponed frequently. The delays in the commissioning of the projects which have always been blamed on financial problems and budget deficit, have added to the expectations of the public from this project and its accomplishment.

The latest comment on the project and its progress has been made by Mayor of Tehran Morteza Alviri which has assessed the project as being uneconomical. Becoming an uneconomical project coupled with prolongation of its implementation is something that has unfortunately befallen a number of other major national projects. It has even left the impression among the public that the project has been too expensive or too much money has been spent on it. Such judgments which are not based on any exact figures are made due to lack of enough information that should have been released by officials in charge of the project. Have those responsible for prolongation of the project which in the opinion of the Tehran mayor is on the verge of becoming economical, been recognized? Should special technical and executive conditions or lack of technical know-how and weak management be blamed for this situation? It seems however that there is no other alternative but to finish the project at whatever expenses.

The following is a summary of official and written information and data released so far about this project which contain some of the features and specifications of it.

The new phase of the project for construction of Tehran Metro, approved by the Cabinet ministers in 1985, has been followed up with partnership of Melli, Sepah, Mellat and Tejarat banks (each with investment shares of 15, 15, 35 and 35 percent), and foreign exchange expenses by means of a contract with companies manufacturing necessary equipment, as guaranteed by the Central Bank of Iran. Over 1,500 billion rial in national currency plus 700 million dollars in hard currency had been spent until March 1998. Contracts for manufacture of fixed and mobile equipment have been signed with three Chinese companies (CNTIC for manufacture of wagons for lines one and two, CITIC for fixed equipment for lines one and two, and NORINCO for equipment needed for Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr express line) and with the Austrian company VOEST ALPINE for production of railway tracks and points. A part of the equipment needed by Tehran Metro will be manufactured domestically. Once operational, the Tehran Metro is expected to transport about 1.5 million passengers through its first and second lines. The following is specification of Tehran Metro lines:

LINE ONE

Line one of the Tehran Metro begins from around Martyr Ayatollah Haqqani highway (Jahan Koudak) in northern Tehran and after crossing Martyr Hemmat highway, Tehran grand prayer site, Martyr Beheshti, Martyr Motahhari, Mofatteh and Saadi avenues, arrives at Imam Khomeini Square. From the Imam Khomeini Square, the line extends to Shoush-Khayyam crossing, South Bus Terminal, Khazaneh, Ali Abad, Javanmard Qassab, Shahr-e Ray, Fath Abad, Honarestan, Shahr-e Sang (stone city) and Shohada to reach the Imam Khomeini Mausoleum and Behesht-e Zahra cemetery. The line is 34,259 meters long of which 14,879 meters go under ground (from Martyr Haqqani highway to Shoush-Khayyam crossing) and 19,830 meters are over ground. The number of stations along this line is 27 of which 15 stations are located underground and 12 over the ground.

LINE TWO

This line starts from Dardasht, east Tehran and after crossing Resalat highway arrives at Martyr Ayatollah Madani (Nezamabad) and then extends to Baharestan Square and Mellat avenues. It crosses line one at Imam Khomeini Square and turns to Azarbaijan and Azadi avenues before reaching southwestern part of the Second Square of Sadeqiyeh. The line is 20,412 meters long of which 19,022 meters are underground and 1,390 meters over the ground. There are 19 stations along this line one of which is shared by line one. Lines one and two of the Tehran Metro are among the top priorities of the project.

TEHRAN - KARAJ - MEHRSHAR EXPRESS LINE

This line starts from the Second Square of Sadeqiyeh and continues up to Mehrshahr, on the outskirts of Karaj, west of Tehran. The line is 41,469 meters long of which 2,499 meters are under the ground and 38,970 meters over the ground. The line has nine stations and one terminal. The stations of this line will be established at Ekbatan township, Azadi Stadium and at townships and factories located along the route. With regards to the rapid progress made in establishment of New Hashtgerd town, the line is expected to continue up to the new town in a near future.

LINE FOUR

Line four begins from Pirouzi-Nirooye Havaie crossing and after going through Shohada and Ibn Sina squares, Enqelab and Azadi Avenues, continues towards Ekbatan township and Mehrabad airport. The line is 15 kilometers long and has 17 stations and one terminal. Two stations of this line are shared by line two. According to the timetable of the project, line two which is a top priority is expected to be completed by the year 2003. Construction operation of the line is scheduled to finish in November 2003 and its equipment installation in February 2004. The line will become operational in four phases. As planned, the first phase of this line will be inaugurated by the end of February 2000. The physical progress of line two has been shown in table 4. As scheduled, line one will be completed by the year 2005 which also includes extension of the line up to the Imam Khomeini Airport.

Construction operation of the line is scheduled to end in November 2005 and its equipment installations in February 2006. The line is to start operation in five phases with the first phase slated for February 2001. The line will be fully commissioned during other phases. According to forecasts, the total expenses needed by the Tehran Metro project from December 1998 until the full commissioning of the lines one and two as well as Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr express line have been estimated at 3,018 billion rials, a major part of which (1,284 billion rials) belongs to letters of credit set aside for purchase of technical equipment from foreign companies.

Construction expenses account for 1,166 billion rials of the said credits. Bedsides these expenditures, the budget allocated for the project cover other expenditures concerning personnel salaries, administrative affairs, insurance, taxes and other relevant spending.

Table 1: This table shows the latest status of equipment needed for Tehran Metro and its suburbs
Row Explanations Party to the contract Type of equipment Net worth of the contract Worth of the contract plus financing interests (in dollars)
1 Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr route CNTIC Wagons for lines one and two 138,250,000167,427,000
2 Lines one and two as well as Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr route NORINCO Wagons and equipment for Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr route 117,000,000 141,556,687
3 Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr route CITIC Fixed equipment for lines one and two (five sections) 313,342,757 404,292,000
4 Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr route CITIC Consulting service 2,900,000 2,900,000
5 Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr route CNTIC Two-storey trains 8,199,000 10,659,000
6 Rail tracks and points VOEST ALPINE Rail tracks and points for lines one and two and for Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr route 46,568,888 68,812,036
Total 626,260,645 795,646,723

Table 2: This table shows the latest status of other equipment for which letters of credit have not been opened.
Row Explanations Party to the contract Type of equipment Net worth of the contract Worth of the contract plus financing interests
1 Lines one and two* NORINO Elevators and lifts 36,193,000 44,793,530
2 Technical inspection construction and transport IEI Inspection of equipment 1,929,240 1,929,240
3 Made at home Pars Wagon 77 domestically-made wagons 29,260,000 35,404,600
4 Made at home SECHERON DC, SWG signals and rectifier 1,066,389 1,066,389
5 Made at home CNTIC Transfer of technology to Pars Wagon 3,350,000 4,053,500
Total 71,798,629 87,247,259
* Elevators and lifts for first priority commissioning worth 15,928,910 dollars are at the stage of opening letters of credit

Table 3: This table shows equipment needed for reaching two minute headway in lines one and two in Tehran and 10 minute headway in Tehran-Mehrshahr route
Row Explanations Number of existing trains Number of additional trains needed Price of every wagon of DC type (thousand dollars) Price of needed trains of DC type (million dollars) Price of every wagon of AC type (thousand dollars) Price of needed trains of AC type (million dollars)
1 Line one* 20 50 600 210 900 315
2 Line two 22 23 600 97 900 145
3 Tehran - Karaj - Mehrshahr** 6 6 600 36 900 54
Total-- 343-- 514
* A `fare collection' tender has been announced but letters of credit have yet to be opened. The cost has been estimated at 20 million dollars.
** A train traveling between Tehran, Karaj and Mehrshahr consists of 8 two-storey wagons and two locomotives

Table 4: This table shows progress in phase one and phase two of construction and commissioning of line two of the Tehran Metro
Beginning of project Progress until end of 1997 Beginning (of new program) End of new program Progress based on new program Progress of whole project
Real Schedule Deviation Real Schedule
Line two of Tehran %36 May 12, 1998 March 18, 2003 %28 %35 %-7 %48 %51
Phase one %58 May 12, 1998 Dec. 20, 1999 %69 %81 %-10 %88 %91
Buildings and route %60 May 12, 1998 Nov. 6, 1999 %57 %76 %-15 %81 %87
Construction and installation of equipment %5 May 12, 1998 Nov. 6, 1999 %75 %84 %-9 %76 %84
Commissioning %0 Nov. 22, 1998 Dec. 6, 1999 %27 %44 %-17 %27 %44
Phase two %51 Aug. 31, 1998 Feb. 4, 2000 %2 %3 %-1 %51 %52
Buildings and route %60 Aug. 31, 1998 Feb. 19, 2000 %2 %3 %-2 %60 %61
Construction and installation of equipment %5 Oct. 14, 1999 Jan. 16, 2000 %0 %0 %0 %5 %5
Commissioning %0 July 23, 1999 Feb. 4, 2000 %0 %0 %0 %0 %0

Back to news index